Basic dimension: definition, the box, and how to report it
The box means no tolerance here
If a dimension is boxed, do not look for plus-or-minus values. A hole located by two boxed dimensions is allowed to be off by the position tolerance in its frame, and that is all. General title-block tolerances do not apply to it.
How to report it
| Option | When |
|---|---|
| Report the result of the governing frame, such as the position error | Usual: the frame is the requirement |
| List the basic value as its own row, with no limits and a note pointing to the frame | If the customer wants every dimension listed |
| Follow the customer's template | If they say otherwise |
A hole position
Boxed 25.00 and 40.00 locate a hole, and the frame says position 0.30. The measured axis is at 25.10 and 40.10, so the position error is 2 x sqrt(0.10^2 + 0.10^2) = 0.2828, which is inside 0.30. Try it in the true position calculator.
Common mistakes
- Giving a basic dimension a plus-or-minus from the title block.
- Reporting the measured coordinate with no result for the frame.
Why a basic dimension has no tolerance
Putting a plus and minus on a dimension that locates a hole would stack with the position tolerance and double count. The boxed value is the exact target and the frame's tolerance is the only allowance, so the whole variation allowed is stated in one place.
Different kinds of basic dimension
Basic dimensions can give a location (25.00 across, 40.00 up), a size (a basic diameter used with a profile tolerance) or an angle (a boxed 45 degrees). In each case the tolerance comes from a frame such as position, profile or angularity.
A second worked example
A slot is located by a boxed 12.00 from datum A and carries a profile tolerance of 0.20. The slot wall measures 12.07 from the datum. The profile frame allows a zone 0.20 wide, so the wall may lie 0.10 either side of 12.00: 12.07 is inside. The title block's general tolerance would never apply, because the dimension is basic.
Practical advice
Check every boxed number against its frame before you balloon. If a boxed dimension has no frame referring to it, the drawing is incomplete and you should ask.
Worked example on the sample part
The sample flanged bushing has a bolt circle printed as 90.0 B.C., and 4X holes of diameter 9.0 plus or minus 0.1 through. On a real drawing the bolt circle diameter would often be boxed, and a position frame on the holes would give the only tolerance. The tool's sample prints the bolt circle with a plain tolerance, so use it here only as an illustration of where a basic dimension would sit: the boxed 90.0 would define the circle on which the four holes lie, and the frame would say how far each hole axis may stray from its exact place on that circle.
Suppose the frame is a position tolerance of 0.30 at MMC. A hole that measures 9.05 against a smallest size of 8.9 has a bonus of 0.15, so the allowed position error is 0.45. The same hole measured at 8.9 would be allowed only 0.30. You can run both cases in the true position calculator.
Basic dimensions and the general tolerance
A general tolerance in the title block applies to dimensions that have no tolerance of their own. A basic dimension is not one of those: it has no tolerance because the frame supplies it. When you set a general tolerance in the tool, do not apply it to boxed values. If a drawing has a boxed value and a frame is missing, that is a drawing error, and the inspector should raise it.
Reading the rectangle
The rectangle can sit around a linear value, an angle or a diameter. On older drawings the abbreviation BSC (basic size) or BASIC beside a number carries the same meaning. If you see one of these words, treat the value as basic.
Mistakes inspectors make
- Typing the boxed value into the tolerance columns as if it were nominal with a plus-minus. The tool then judges the measured coordinate against limits the drawing never gave.
- Reporting only coordinates and not the result of the frame, so the reviewer cannot see whether the position was met.
- Applying the title-block tolerance to the boxed value and passing a part that fails its frame.
- Forgetting that datums set the origin: a coordinate measured from the wrong datum is meaningless against a boxed value.
- What is a basic dimension in GD&T?
- A boxed, theoretically exact value that gets its tolerance from a feature control frame.
- How do I report basic dimensions on a first article?
- Report the governing frame's result; list the basic value only if asked.
- Does a basic dimension ever get a plus-minus tolerance?
- No. A basic dimension has no tolerance of its own. The tolerance comes from the feature control frame that refers to it, such as position or profile. If a boxed value also shows a plus-minus, the drawing is inconsistent and should be queried with the drawing owner before inspection.
- Does the general tolerance in the title block apply to a basic dimension?
- No. The general tolerance covers dimensions that have no tolerance of their own. A boxed value is controlled through its frame, so applying the title-block tolerance to it would give limits the drawing never intended.
- What does BSC mean on a drawing?
- BSC stands for basic size, and on older drawings it marks a basic dimension in the same way a rectangle does. Treat it as a theoretically exact value that gets its tolerance from a frame.