Reference dimension: definition, brackets and whether to inspect it
Reference, basic and toleranced
| Kind | Looks like | Tolerance comes from | Inspect it? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toleranced | 20.0 plus or minus 0.2 | Itself | Yes |
| Basic | Boxed 25.00 | A feature control frame | Through the frame |
| Reference | (25.0) or 25.0 REF | None | No, unless the customer says so |
Do reference dimensions go on a first article report?
Normally no, because they are not requirements. Some customers want them listed anyway: do what the customer states and note that it is a reference value.
What it is for
A reference value saves the reader from adding two numbers. If an overall length is the sum of three features, the overall length may be shown as a reference. Checking it adds nothing but confusion if the stack-up disagrees: the toleranced dimensions rule.
Common mistakes
- Ballooning a reference dimension and then reporting a pass or fail for it.
- Treating brackets as a tolerance.
How to spot one
Look for the value in parentheses, or followed by REF. Older drawings may use other conventions, so check the notes. If the number has no tolerance, is not boxed and is not in parentheses, it is not a reference dimension: it is covered by the general tolerance in the title block.
A worked example
A plate is 60.0 plus or minus 0.2 overall, with a step of 25.0 plus or minus 0.1 on one side, and a second step shown as (35.0). The 35.0 is a reference value, found by subtracting 25.0 from 60.0. Its limits would work out to 34.7 to 35.3 by adding the tolerances, but the drawing does not ask you to inspect it. If you measured 35.4 you would not reject the part on that figure: you would look at the toleranced dimensions that produce it.
Conflicts between a reference and the rest
When a reference value disagrees with the arithmetic of the toleranced dimensions, the toleranced dimensions rule. Report the discrepancy to the drawing owner, because it usually means the drawing needs a correction rather than that the part is wrong.
In the report
The default is no balloon for a reference dimension. Where the customer asks for one, enter the value as given, add a note saying it is a reference value and leave the verdict blank or mark it as not applicable.
Worked example on the sample part
The sample drawing has two linear dimensions, 20.0 plus or minus 0.2 and 70.0 plus or minus 0.3. If a designer wanted to show the difference between them for information, they could print it as (50.0). That value would be derived: it has no tolerance of its own, and its spread would come out as 49.5 to 50.5 only by adding the two tolerances, which is exactly why inspectors are not asked to check it. The ballooned sample therefore carries seven balloons and no balloon for a reference value.
If a customer did ask for the reference value to be listed, the report row would read requirement 50.0 REF, no limits and a note saying it is a reference value, and the verdict would stay blank.
Reference, basic and general: telling them apart
| What you see | Kind | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| 50.0 plus or minus 0.2 | Toleranced | Balloon it and judge it against its limits |
| Boxed 25.00 | Basic | Judge the frame that refers to it |
| (50.0) or 50.0 REF | Reference | No balloon unless the customer asks |
| 36.50 with no tolerance, no box, no brackets | Toleranced by the title block | Balloon it and apply the general tolerance |
Why reference dimensions disagree with measurements
A reference value is the sum or difference of other dimensions, so it carries all their variation. Measure it and you may find a value outside the apparent limits without any toleranced dimension being out of tolerance. That is not a defect. It is the reason such values are not requirements.
Mistakes inspectors make
- Ballooning a reference dimension and then rejecting a part on it.
- Treating brackets as a tolerance or as a note.
- Missing that a number in brackets on an older drawing may mean something else: read the drawing's own notes.
- What is a reference dimension?
- A value in brackets or marked REF, for information only.
- Is it inspected?
- Not unless the customer requires it.
- What is the symbol for a reference dimension?
- A reference dimension is shown in parentheses, for example (50.0), or marked REF after the value. Some older drawings use other conventions, so check the drawing's notes. Either way, the value is for information only and is not a requirement.
- Can a reference dimension be rejected?
- Not on its own. It has no tolerance and is derived from other dimensions. If a measurement disagrees with it, check the toleranced dimensions that produce it, and tell the drawing owner if the drawing looks wrong.
- Should reference dimensions be ballooned?
- Normally no, because they are not inspected. Where a customer asks for them to be listed, give them a row marked as a reference value with no limits and no verdict.