PPAP dimensional results explained, and how they differ from a first article report
At a glance
| First article inspection | PPAP dimensional results | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Every characteristic on the drawing, plus materials and processes | One element of a larger approval package |
| Industry | Aerospace and defence in particular | Automotive in particular, and other industries that adopted it |
| Governing document | The standard or customer clause named in the contract | The PPAP manual and the customer's requirements |
| What is submitted | A report in the layout the customer requires | A table of dimensional results for the parts the customer specifies |
| Role of the ballooned drawing | Each characteristic is numbered and traced to a report row | The same, so each result is tied to a feature |
In one sentence: an FAI report accounts for every characteristic of the first part from a process, while PPAP dimensional results are one part of a package that approves a production process.
What each one answers
A first article inspection answers: does this first part meet every requirement? A PPAP package answers a wider question: can this process make conforming parts repeatedly, and is there documentation behind it? The dimensional results are only one element of a PPAP package, which also carries items such as process flow and control documents. This page covers just the dimensional part.
What the table looks like
The table is organised around the same ballooned drawing. Each balloon is a row. For each row there is the requirement, the tolerance, and then a set of measured results from several parts, with an overall assessment. Because several parts are measured, the table has a column for each part.
The tool supports this with Tolerances and parts: choose the number of measured parts and each balloon gets that many result columns. You can paste a block of results from a spreadsheet and the values fill across and down. A row is out of tolerance if any measured part is out.
One drawing, two documents
If a customer asks for both, the work is the same up to the point of measuring: balloon the drawing, record each requirement, measure. Then a first article report lists one result per row, while the dimensional results table lists a result per part. A report with several result columns serves both purposes in many shops, but your customer's format decides.
| No. | Requirement | Min | Max | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 20.0 ±0.2 | 19.8 | 20.2 | 20.08 | IN TOL |
| 2 | 70.0 ±0.3 | 69.7 | 70.3 | 69.91 | IN TOL |
| 3 | ⌀110.0 ±0.1 | 109.9 | 110.1 | 110.04 | IN TOL |
| 4 | ⌀70.0 +0.03/0 | 70.0 | 70.03 | 70.02 | IN TOL |
| 5 | ⌀30.00 +0.02/0 | 30.00 | 30.02 | 30.01 | IN TOL |
| 6 | 4X ⌀9.0 ±0.1 THRU | 8.9 | 9.1 | 9.05 | IN TOL |
| 7 | ⌀90.0 ±0.1 B.C. | 89.9 | 90.1 | 90.03 | IN TOL |
Common mistakes
- Measuring fewer parts than the customer's requirement states.
- Mixing parts from different cavities or fixtures in the same column without saying so.
- Leaving a part's result blank when it was not measured; say so instead.
Worked example on the sample part
The same sample drawing can feed either report. For an FAI package you balloon it, measure the seven characteristics on the first part and record the seven rows. For PPAP dimensional results the customer might ask for several parts: the same seven rows would be repeated for each part, as measured columns, so a reviewer can see the spread. The tool supports several measured parts for exactly this case, with a verdict per part.
| No. | Requirement | Min | Max | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 20.0 ±0.2 | 19.8 | 20.2 | 20.08 | IN TOL |
| 2 | 70.0 ±0.3 | 69.7 | 70.3 | 69.91 | IN TOL |
| 3 | ⌀110.0 ±0.1 | 109.9 | 110.1 | 110.04 | IN TOL |
| 4 | ⌀70.0 +0.03/0 | 70.0 | 70.03 | 70.02 | IN TOL |
| 5 | ⌀30.00 +0.02/0 | 30.00 | 30.02 | 30.01 | IN TOL |
| 6 | 4X ⌀9.0 ±0.1 THRU | 8.9 | 9.1 | 9.05 | IN TOL |
| 7 | ⌀90.0 ±0.1 B.C. | 89.9 | 90.1 | 90.03 | IN TOL |
Take row 4, limits 70.00 to 70.03. For one part the report shows one result. For a PPAP-style set it might show five results side by side, and a reviewer can see at a glance whether all five are inside the limits and how close to the upper limit they run. A set of five readings that all sit at 70.03 would tell a different story from five scattered across the range, even though all are in tolerance.
What is the same and what differs
The measuring is the same. The ballooned drawing is the same. The difference is in the package: FAI wraps the table with part identity and material and process accounting, while PPAP wraps it with the other approval elements such as the control plan and process studies. Both rely on the same underlying evidence: a numbered characteristic with a measured result.
Terms that get confused
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| FAI | First article inspection |
| FAIR | First article inspection report |
| PPAP | Production part approval process |
| PSW | Part submission warrant, one PPAP document |
| ISIR | Initial sample inspection report, a term used by some customers for a first-sample dimensional report |
Mistakes people make
- Submitting an FAI report where PPAP was asked for, or the reverse.
- Measuring a single part when the customer asked for several.
- Forgetting the drawing revision on the table.
- Is a PPAP the same as FAI?
- No. FAI proves a first article; PPAP proves a production process and carries more than a dimensional table.
- Can I use the same ballooned drawing for both?
- Usually yes, because both are keyed to the same balloon numbers.
- What is the difference between PPAP and first article inspection?
- FAI documents the inspection of the first parts from a process against every drawing requirement. PPAP is a wider approval package of which dimensional results are one element. Both use a ballooned drawing and a table of results.
- What is ISIR in quality?
- ISIR stands for initial sample inspection report. Some customers use it for a dimensional report on first samples, similar in purpose to a first article report. Ask the customer which layout they want.
- What are PPAP dimensional results?
- A table of dimensional results for the parts the customer specifies, with the specification, the measured values and an assessment for each characteristic. A ballooned drawing ties each result to a feature.
- Can the same report serve FAI and PPAP?
- Often the table can be reused, but the package around it differs. Check what each requirement asks for, including the number of parts and the layout.