Surface finish symbols: what they mean and how to report one
Variants
| Mark | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Check mark | Surface finish applies, process not stated |
| Check mark with a bar | Material removal by machining is required |
| Check mark with a circle | Material removal is prohibited |
| Ra with a number | Arithmetical mean roughness limit |
Example row
| No. | Requirement | Max | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Surface finish Ra 1.6 max | 1.6 | 1.2 | Within tolerance |
The values are an example. A profilometer is the usual instrument; note it in the tooling column.
Common mistakes
- Reading Ra in micro-inches as micrometres.
- Forgetting that finish applies to the surface the symbol touches.
What Ra means
Ra is the arithmetical mean roughness: the average height of the peaks and valleys of a surface over a sampling length, measured by a profilometer that drags a fine stylus across it. A smaller number is a smoother surface. Typical drawing values are given in micrometres, and older drawings in micro-inches. Do not mix them: one micro-inch is about 0.0254 micrometres, so Ra 63 micro-inch is about 1.6 micrometres.
Other roughness parameters
Rz, the average maximum height, is another common parameter, and some drawings state both. The symbol or the note says which one applies. If the parameter is not named, ask before you measure.
Where the symbol sits
The symbol touches the surface it controls, or its extension line, or a leader pointing to it. A note near the title block, such as a finish that applies to all surfaces unless otherwise marked, covers surfaces without their own symbol. Count the surfaces carefully, because each distinct requirement is a characteristic.
Reporting several surfaces
Give each surface its own row if the values differ, with a note on which surface it is. Where several surfaces carry the same requirement, you may report one row with several results, as with a quantity callout.
Mistakes to avoid
- Measuring across the lay of the machining marks instead of with the direction the drawing asks.
- Reporting a roughness as a dimension in the wrong units.
- Missing the general note that applies a finish to every unmarked surface.
Worked example report rows
The sample part does not print a surface finish, so this example is invented, labelled as such, and uses two of the sample's diameters as the surfaces. Suppose the 70.0 diameter (balloon 4) is to be Ra 0.8 maximum and the 30.00 diameter (balloon 5) Ra 1.6 maximum. The report would carry two extra rows after the seven, numbered 8 and 9:
| No. | Requirement | Max | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Surface finish Ra 0.8 max, 70.0 diameter | 0.8 | 0.6 | In tolerance |
| 9 | Surface finish Ra 1.6 max, 30.00 diameter | 1.6 | 1.7 | Out of tolerance by 0.1 |
The results are examples. A measured 1.7 on a limit of 1.6 fails, and a note would say what was done. In the tool, enter the requirement as text, set the maximum as the upper limit with no lower limit, and enter the result.
Roughness parameters in plain words
Ra is the average height of the profile over the sampling length. A surface can have a good Ra and still have one deep scratch, which is why some drawings also give Rz, the average of the largest peak-to-valley heights over several sampling lengths. Rz is normally larger than Ra for the same surface. If a drawing gives only a number with no parameter, ask which one is meant.
The lay symbol
A symbol beside the check mark shows the direction of the machining marks: parallel, perpendicular, crossed, circular or random. It matters because a profilometer measures across the marks to give the representative reading. Where a lay symbol is shown, trace across the lay.
Typical values and processes
As a rough guide for orientation, not a requirement: a fine turned or ground surface gives lower Ra than a milled one, and a cast surface gives a rougher one. Do not infer a requirement from the process. Use what the drawing prints.
Mistakes inspectors make
- Taking a reading along the lay instead of across it and reporting a better value than the surface really has.
- Reporting units wrongly. Micrometres and micro-inches differ by a factor of about 40.
- Measuring on a curved surface with a flat-surface stylus set-up.
- Forgetting that a general finish note covers every unmarked surface.
- What do the surface finish symbols on a drawing mean?
- See the variants table above.
- What is Ra on a drawing?
- Ra is the arithmetical mean roughness: the average height of the surface profile over a sampling length, usually in micrometres. A smaller number is a smoother surface. A profilometer measures it by dragging a fine stylus across the surface.
- How do I measure surface roughness?
- With a profilometer: a stylus drawn across the surface, across the direction of the machining marks, over the sampling length the instrument or drawing gives. Record the reading, the parameter and the instrument in the report row.
- What is the difference between Ra and Rz?
- Ra averages the profile heights, while Rz averages the largest peak-to-valley heights over several sampling lengths. Rz is usually larger for the same surface. Report whichever parameter the drawing names and never swap one for the other.